GIULIO PAOLINI – TEORIA DELLE APPARENZE

By 16 January 2018 Exhibitions, Giulio Paolini

GIULIO PAOLINI

TEORIA DELLE APPARENZE
16 January to 14 April 2018

GIULIO PAOLINI

TEORIA DELLE APPARENZE
16 January to 14 April 2018

Text

Galleria Fumagalli presents the exhibition “Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle apparenze”, a selection of works from 1969 to 2015. Embracing the whole production of the artist, issued from a conceptual area of research, the exhibition gives an overview of Giulio Paolini’s work: from the perspective paintings of the ‘70s, to the theatrical and literary dimension of the ‘80s, until the recent studies on the author identity and his condition as a spectator.
The founding moment of Giulio Paolini’s artistic research dates back to “Disegno geometrico” from 1960, a small canvas (40×60 cm) on which the artist traced the squaring of the surface. From this moment on, Giulio Paolini identifies as his field of interest the fundaments of vision and the methods of the artistic work. Thereafter, he develops a decoding process free from image processing and close to sign, geometric vision and mathematics. The selected works displayed in the exhibition “Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle apparenze” follow the artist’s path starting from 1969 with the work “Quam raptim ad sublimia”, a cotton standard with the Latin inscription “to the sublime as soon as possible”. The phrase, taken by the artist from a brass engraving in the marble floor of the Vatican Museum, evokes the ineffable nature of words. As for language as for painting, the artist explores with a retrospective attitude the mechanisms and the constitutive elements of showing: from literary quotations to self-reference, he proposes a historicization of his own work. Deceptive perspectival lines and images, in works such as “Teoria delle apparenze” (1972) and “Equivalenza” (1975), are virtual propositions of space and allude to the idea of the painting as a potential repository for all past and future works. Since the mid-70s, themes such as repetition and circularity of references are present in the work of Giulio Paolini. Thanks also to the use of plaster casts of statues or classical architectural details, the artist reflects on tradition as only perceivable in fragments.

Representative in this sense are “L’arte e lo spazio, quattro illustrazioni per uno scritto di Martin Heidegger” (1983), a reference to the “four observations” of the German philosopher paradigm of the aesthetic discourse in those years, and “Grandezza Naturale” (1986/87), which questions the meaning and the paradox of the notion of “natural”. The photographic collage “Comédie Italienne” (1984) is a documentation of the scenic fragment created by the artist with Carlo Quartucci in 1983 at the Ninfeo del Bramante, inspired by the famous painting by Jean-Antoine Watteau ”Embarquement pour Cyhtère”. The work evokes the myth of the eternal journey of Italian comedians and refers to another characteristic aspect of Giulio Paolini’s oeuvre: the theatricalization of the work. Also “L’Indifferent” (1992) is a reference to the Watteau painting of 1717, reproduced in a color photograph (missing some parts cut out by the artist) and framed on a wooden easel. The visual perception is challenged and actively involves the viewer in the definition of the work. Emblematic is “Terra di nessuno” (2013/2014), an easel with a canvas and four fragments of a perspective drawing in a showcase evoking a painting yet not reveling it. Also on show “Studio per Da lontano” (2015), a preparatory drawing of Giulio Paolini’s intervention for the Baroque temple of Museo Cappella Sansevero in Naples, and “Studio per Villa dei misteri” (2013), a composition of images in perspective whose title is inspired by the Pompeian domus. With the exhibition “Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle apparenze”, Galleria Fumagalli pays homage to one of the most representative artists of the Italian avant-garde. Through installation, drawing, collage, plaster cast and photography, from the ’60s till today, Giulio Paolini explores the tautological and metaphysical nature of the artistic practice questioning its method structures and regenerating the work in always new perspectives. “My way of operating is in relationship, a continuous relay, between the previous and upcoming artwork. Every painting is ultimately the replica of the previous one (I would say that it comes to life as a replica of the previous one)”. (Giulio Paolini in “Dipingere la pittura”, interview by Nico Orengo in “Fuoricampo”, Turin 1973).

Giulio Paolini was born in Genoa in 1940, he lives and works in Turin. From the beginning in the early 60s his analytical research affirms the work of art as a pure attestation of itself and as a specific linguistic tool of the artistic field. Starting from the exposition of the material codes of the painting system (such as the white canvas, the sheet, the frame, etc.) Giulio Paolini’s interest is turned to representation as a category of expressivity, moving an investigation on art starting from its history and as a sedimentation of a knowledge to be questioned always. Over the years his work has been shown in eminent international public institutions, among the latest solo shows: Center for Italian Modern Art, New York and Museo Poldi Pezzoli, Milan (2016), Macro, Rome (2013), Palazzo delle Esposizioni, Rome (2010), Kunstmuseum, Winterthur and Westfälisches Landesmuseum, Münster (2005), Mart, Rovereto (2004), Fondazione Prada, Milan (2003), CEAAC, Strasbourg and GAM, Turin (2001), Museo d’Arte Contemporanea Castello di Rivoli, Turin (1999, 1991, 1986), Mamco, Geneve (1999), Neue Galerie, Graz (1998), Palazzo della Ragione, Padua (1995), Kunstmuseum, Winterthur (1993), Kölnischer Kunstverein, Koln and Museo di Capodimonte, Naples (1988), Musée d’art contemporain, Montréal (1985), PAC, Milan and Neuer Berliner Kunstverein, Berlin (1982), Galleria Nazionale d’Arte Moderna, Rome (1981), Stedelijk Museum, Amsterdam and Museum of Modern Art, Oxford (1980), Musée d’Art Moderne de la Ville de Paris (1978), Museum of Modern Art, New York (1974). His works are permanently displayed in public and private institutions all over the world such as Museo d’Arte Contemporanea Castello di Rivoli, Turin; Centro per l’arte contemporanea Luigi Pecci, Prato; FRAC Bourgogne, Dijon; Galleria nazionale d’arte moderna and contemporanea, Rome; Mart, Rovereto; MAXXI, Rome; Musée d’art contemporain, Montréal; Musée d’Art Moderne, Brussels; Musée des Beaux-Arts, Nantes; Museo del Novecento, Milan; Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam; Museum Moderner Kunst Stiftung Ludwig, Vienna; National Gallery of Art, Washington D.C.; Nationalgalerie, Berlin; Museum of Modern Art, San Francisco; Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, New York; Stedelijk Museum, Amsterdam; Tate, London; The Art Institute, Chicago; Walker Art Center, Minneapolis.

Text

Galleria Fumagalli presents the exhibition “Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle apparenze”, a selection of works from 1969 to 2015. Embracing the whole production of the artist, issued from a conceptual area of research, the exhibition gives an overview of Giulio Paolini’s work: from the perspective paintings of the ‘70s, to the theatrical and literary dimension of the ‘80s, until the recent studies on the author identity and his condition as a spectator.
The founding moment of Giulio Paolini’s artistic research dates back to “Disegno geometrico” from 1960, a small canvas (40×60 cm) on which the artist traced the squaring of the surface. From this moment on, Giulio Paolini identifies as his field of interest the fundaments of vision and the methods of the artistic work. Thereafter, he develops a decoding process free from image processing and close to sign, geometric vision and mathematics. The selected works displayed in the exhibition “Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle apparenze” follow the artist’s path starting from 1969 with the work “Quam raptim ad sublimia”, a cotton standard with the Latin inscription “to the sublime as soon as possible”. The phrase, taken by the artist from a brass engraving in the marble floor of the Vatican Museum, evokes the ineffable nature of words. As for language as for painting, the artist explores with a retrospective attitude the mechanisms and the constitutive elements of showing: from literary quotations to self-reference, he proposes a historicization of his own work. Deceptive perspectival lines and images, in works such as “Teoria delle apparenze” (1972) and “Equivalenza” (1975), are virtual propositions of space and allude to the idea of the painting as a potential repository for all past and future works. Since the mid-70s, themes such as repetition and circularity of references are present in the work of Giulio Paolini. Thanks also to the use of plaster casts of statues or classical architectural details, the artist reflects on tradition as only perceivable in fragments.

Representative in this sense are “L’arte e lo spazio, quattro illustrazioni per uno scritto di Martin Heidegger” (1983), a reference to the “four observations” of the German philosopher paradigm of the aesthetic discourse in those years, and “Grandezza Naturale” (1986/87), which questions the meaning and the paradox of the notion of “natural”. The photographic collage “Comédie Italienne” (1984) is a documentation of the scenic fragment created by the artist with Carlo Quartucci in 1983 at the Ninfeo del Bramante, inspired by the famous painting by Jean-Antoine Watteau ”Embarquement pour Cyhtère”. The work evokes the myth of the eternal journey of Italian comedians and refers to another characteristic aspect of Giulio Paolini’s oeuvre: the theatricalization of the work. Also “L’Indifferent” (1992) is a reference to the Watteau painting of 1717, reproduced in a color photograph (missing some parts cut out by the artist) and framed on a wooden easel. The visual perception is challenged and actively involves the viewer in the definition of the work. Emblematic is “Terra di nessuno” (2013/2014), an easel with a canvas and four fragments of a perspective drawing in a showcase evoking a painting yet not reveling it. Also on show “Studio per Da lontano” (2015), a preparatory drawing of Giulio Paolini’s intervention for the Baroque temple of Museo Cappella Sansevero in Naples, and “Studio per Villa dei misteri” (2013), a composition of images in perspective whose title is inspired by the Pompeian domus. With the exhibition “Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle apparenze”, Galleria Fumagalli pays homage to one of the most representative artists of the Italian avant-garde. Through installation, drawing, collage, plaster cast and photography, from the ’60s till today, Giulio Paolini explores the tautological and metaphysical nature of the artistic practice questioning its method structures and regenerating the work in always new perspectives. “My way of operating is in relationship, a continuous relay, between the previous and upcoming artwork. Every painting is ultimately the replica of the previous one (I would say that it comes to life as a replica of the previous one)”. (Giulio Paolini in “Dipingere la pittura”, interview by Nico Orengo in “Fuoricampo”, Turin 1973).

Giulio Paolini was born in Genoa in 1940, he lives and works in Turin. From the beginning in the early 60s his analytical research affirms the work of art as a pure attestation of itself and as a specific linguistic tool of the artistic field. Starting from the exposition of the material codes of the painting system (such as the white canvas, the sheet, the frame, etc.) Giulio Paolini’s interest is turned to representation as a category of expressivity, moving an investigation on art starting from its history and as a sedimentation of a knowledge to be questioned always. Over the years his work has been shown in eminent international public institutions, among the latest solo shows: Center for Italian Modern Art, New York and Museo Poldi Pezzoli, Milan (2016), Macro, Rome (2013), Palazzo delle Esposizioni, Rome (2010), Kunstmuseum, Winterthur and Westfälisches Landesmuseum, Münster (2005), Mart, Rovereto (2004), Fondazione Prada, Milan (2003), CEAAC, Strasbourg and GAM, Turin (2001), Museo d’Arte Contemporanea Castello di Rivoli, Turin (1999, 1991, 1986), Mamco, Geneve (1999), Neue Galerie, Graz (1998), Palazzo della Ragione, Padua (1995), Kunstmuseum, Winterthur (1993), Kölnischer Kunstverein, Koln and Museo di Capodimonte, Naples (1988), Musée d’art contemporain, Montréal (1985), PAC, Milan and Neuer Berliner Kunstverein, Berlin (1982), Galleria Nazionale d’Arte Moderna, Rome (1981), Stedelijk Museum, Amsterdam and Museum of Modern Art, Oxford (1980), Musée d’Art Moderne de la Ville de Paris (1978), Museum of Modern Art, New York (1974). His works are permanently displayed in public and private institutions all over the world such as Museo d’Arte Contemporanea Castello di Rivoli, Turin; Centro per l’arte contemporanea Luigi Pecci, Prato; FRAC Bourgogne, Dijon; Galleria nazionale d’arte moderna and contemporanea, Rome; Mart, Rovereto; MAXXI, Rome; Musée d’art contemporain, Montréal; Musée d’Art Moderne, Brussels; Musée des Beaux-Arts, Nantes; Museo del Novecento, Milan; Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam; Museum Moderner Kunst Stiftung Ludwig, Vienna; National Gallery of Art, Washington D.C.; Nationalgalerie, Berlin; Museum of Modern Art, San Francisco; Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, New York; Stedelijk Museum, Amsterdam; Tate, London; The Art Institute, Chicago; Walker Art Center, Minneapolis.

Installation views

Giulio Paolini, Teoria delle apparenze, 2018. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle Apparenze, 2018
Galleria Fumagalli Milano. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini, Teoria delle apparenze, 2018. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle Apparenze, 2018
Galleria Fumagalli Milano. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini, Teoria delle apparenze, 2018. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle Apparenze, 2018
Galleria Fumagalli Milano. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini, Teoria delle apparenze, 2018. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle Apparenze, 2018
Galleria Fumagalli Milano. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini, Teoria delle apparenze, 2018. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle Apparenze, 2018
Galleria Fumagalli Milano. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini, Teoria delle apparenze, 2018. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle Apparenze, 2018
Galleria Fumagalli Milano. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini, Teoria delle apparenze, 2018. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle Apparenze, 2018
Galleria Fumagalli Milano. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini, Teoria delle apparenze, 2018. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle Apparenze, 2018
Galleria Fumagalli Milano. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini, Teoria delle apparenze, 2018. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle Apparenze, 2018
Galleria Fumagalli Milano. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini, Teoria delle apparenze, 2018. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle Apparenze, 2018
Galleria Fumagalli Milano. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini, Teoria delle apparenze, 2018. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle Apparenze, 2018
Galleria Fumagalli Milano. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini, Teoria delle apparenze, 2018. Ph Antonio Maniscalco
Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle Apparenze, 2018
Galleria Fumagalli Milano. Ph Antonio Maniscalco

Installation views

Press

All Art

March 2018
“Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle apparenze”

Read article  →

Il Giornale dell’Arte

January 2018
“Apparenze, equivalenze, indifferenze. Giuio Paolini da Fumagalli”

Read article  →

artribune.com

30 January 2018
“Apparenze e teoria. Giulio Paolini a Milano”

Read article  →

Flash Art

17 April 2018
“Giulio Paolini. Fumagalli / Milano”

Read article  →

Arte

January 2018
“Giulio Paolini. Teatro dell’evocazione”

Read article  →

Press

All Art

March 2018
“Giulio Paolini. Teoria delle apparenze”

Read article  →

Il Giornale dell’Arte

January 2018
“Apparenze, equivalenze, indifferenze. Giuio Paolini da Fumagalli”

Read article  →

artribune.com

30 January 2018
“Apparenze e teoria. Giulio Paolini a Milano”

Read article  →

Flash Art

17 April 2018
“Giulio Paolini. Fumagalli / Milano”

Read article  →

Arte

January 2018
“Giulio Paolini. Teatro dell’evocazione”

Read article  →

JOIN OUR MAILING LIST

Join the discussion 12 Comments

  • Hier können Sie Online Roulette kostenlos spielen, ganz ohne
    Anmeldung oder Download. Nein, wenn Sie Slots kostenlos spielen, spielen Sie direkt im Browser.

    Bei uns können Sie in über 200 Varianten Roulette kostenlos spielen.
    Wenn Sie mehr aus Demo Casino herausholen möchten, verwenden Sie unsere
    Promo-Codes, um Sonderangebote zu erhalten. Die Teilnahme am Wettbewerb
    ist normalerweise kostenlos, sofern Sie einige einfache
    Anforderungen erfüllen. Demo-Casino-Turniere sind eine großartige Möglichkeit,
    zusätzliche Belohnungen zu erhalten und zu sehen, wie gut Sie im Vergleich zu anderen Spielern abschneiden. Demo Casino baut diese Boni auf dem auf, was Sie tun, und es gibt keine
    versteckten Bedingungen oder schwer verständlichen Schritte, um sie zu erhalten. Für
    Leute, die möchten, dass alles beim Alten bleibt, bieten unsere Cashback-Angebote eine stetige Rendite auf mögliche
    Verluste innerhalb der Woche.
    Alle Freispiele in unserem Online-Demo-Casino sind für Sie kostenlos, aber das heißt
    nicht, dass Sie Ihre Gratis-Credits nicht einplanen sollten. Bei diesen Glücksspielen können Sie unbegrenzt Demo-Credits auf Ihre Lieblingsspiele mit Live-Dealer
    setzen. Wenn Sie versuchen würden, diese Slots mit echtem Geld und selbst
    mit dem kleinsten Einsatz zu spielen, würde Ihr Spielguthaben schnell aufgebraucht sein. Neben kostenlosen Demo-Slots für virtuelles Spielen bieten wir
    unseren Besuchern und Mitgliedern unten einen umfassenden Leitfaden zu unserem virtuellen Casino,
    damit Sie unsere Demo-Slots-Plattform optimal nutzen können.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/sofortige-casino-freispiele-der-schnellste-weg-zum-gluck/

  • Wählen Sie aus über 3.000 Spielen und profitieren Sie von Ihrem Willkommensbonus.
    Slots, Live-Casino, Tischspiele und mehr von führenden Anbietern wie NetEnt, Pragmatic Play und Evolution Gaming.
    Wir bieten Ihnen ein sicheres, faires und unterhaltsames Spielerlebnis mit modernster Technologie und erstklassigem Service.

    Ally Spin bietet großzügige Willkommensangebote, Freispiele
    und Cashback-Aktionen. Der wöchentliche Reload-Bonus bietet 50 Freispiele für eine Einzahlung ab 20 €.
    Mit verschiedenen Bonusarten, einschließlich Einzahlungsboni und Cashback-Angeboten,
    haben Spieler die Chance, zusätzliche Gelder und Freispiele zu erhalten. Treten Sie noch heute dem AllySpin Casino bei und entdecken Sie endlose
    Unterhaltung, großzügige Belohnungen und eine vertrauenswürdige Plattform, auf der Sie unbesorgt spielen können. Egal, ob
    Sie wegen der aufregenden Spielautomaten, der fesselnden Live-Casinospiele
    oder der Sportwetten hier sind, AllySpin Casino bietet für jeden etwas.

    Dies gewährleistet ein reibungsloses Spielerlebnis, insbesondere bei Live-Casinospielen.
    Das Allyspin Casino überzeugt uns vorwiegend mit einer breiten Auswahl an Spielautomaten, Tischspielen und
    einem umfangreichen Angebot an Live Casino Spielen. Wichtig ist dabei
    lediglich eine stabile Internetverbindung, vor allem dann, wenn du im Live Casino spielen möchtest.
    Für Spieler, die neben Deutsch auch andere Sprachen sprechen, bietet das Casino auch internationale Tischspiele an. Mit einer umfassenden Auswahl an Live
    Dealer Spielen und Tischspielen, die für abwechslungsreiche Unterhaltung sorgen, kann das Allyspin Casino in unserem
    Test punkten.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/legzo-casino-meine-umfassenden-erfahrungen-seit-10-jahren/

  • You can not move on to a column containing
    2 or more of your opponents pieces. If you move on to
    a column contaning one of your opponents pieces their piece will be sent back to the start.
    Please either enable Javascript for Cardgames.io from your
    brower’s security settings, or upgrade to a more modern browser.
    Unfortunately, all the games are coded in Javascript,
    and so our site cannot function without executing scripts.
    We detected that something blocked cardgames.io from running Javascript files
    on the page. The primary script that runs our games seems to not
    have loaded, somehow.
    If playing with friends, you could always ask them for some advice before you start playing.

    For example, you could watch Backgammon tutorials or games on sites
    such as YouTube to better familarize yourself with the rules!
    However, if you are looking to put your skills to the test, you may want to play against another human player
    instead. When playing 24/7 Backgammon, your home point is in the bottom left corner of the screen. A die
    is used to raise the stakes when playing Backgammon. A prime is a series of six consecutive points occupied by your checkers.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/the-star-sydney-a-complete-overview-for-online-players/

  • For instance, you could share your local Mongo DB server.
    That means that you can share something like a
    database or a Redis cache. With VS Live Share, you can share that localhost so that the
    other person can access it just like it was their own localhost.

    Nifty Gateway is a standout among NFT marketplaces, known for its curated approach
    and cost-effective features. If you’re exploring the best NFT marketplaces, OpenSea should be on your radar.
    For buyers, its search tools make navigating the art marketplace a breeze.
    While most listings are on the Ethereum blockchain, OpenSea’s versatility appeals to creators and collectors alike.

    The NFT marketplace supports blockchain technology
    like Ethereum, Polygon, and Klaytn. With over 80 million NFTs and $10 billion in transaction volume, it’s
    no wonder many call it a top NFT trading platform.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/excalibur-hotel-casino-in-depth-review/

  • Monitor, access, and support your IT fleet
    regardless of the destination. Selecting a region changes the
    language and/or content on teamviewer.com TeamViewer prioritizes security and uses full encryption to protect your
    connections.
    Our HIPAA and GDPR-compliant security protocols ensure sensitive information remains protected.
    Every connection is safeguarded, giving you complete peace of mind.
    “Twenty minutes worth of work by our technical team here is the equivalent of $2,500 worth of contractor visits and days of planning, to do the exact same thing.” “TeamViewer is being embraced by so many users at Demant because of its efficiency and simplicity.” To deliver exceptional education, Edith Cowan University (ECU) relies on exceptional IT support.

    Using our web app, you can start sessions directly from your
    browser to connect with saved contacts or devices,
    generate session links or session codes, or connect with TeamViewer IDs.

    TeamViewer QuickSupport, on the other hand, is designed for end users to receive remote IT support.
    Looking for downloads for other operating systems, mobile devices, and more?
    With cross-platform functionality that works across
    Windows, Mac, Linux, iOS, and Android devices, digital nomads can maintain their preferred workflow regardless of which devices they carry
    on their travels.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/free-18-unlock-your-bonus-today/

  • The platform collaborates with leading game developers like
    NetEnt, Microgaming, and Play’n GO, ensuring access to a diverse range of high-quality games.
    In line with modern financial trends, King Billy Casino supports cryptocurrency withdrawals, allowing players to use Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin, and Tether for secure and
    anonymous transactions. Credit and debit cards like Visa and MasterCard are
    popular options, offering the convenience of direct transfers to players’ bank accounts.
    Launched in recent years, it has gained popularity among online gamers for its
    user-friendly interface, attractive bonuses, and promotions.

    It is an excellent starting point for discovering the platform.
    Bonuses on initial deposits and extra free spins help increase the balance and extend the fun. Thus, KingBilly Casino provides users
    with a secure gaming environment in which all applicable laws and regulations of the jurisdiction are
    strictly observed. King Billy Casino play is highly rewarding,
    safe, and constantly engaging. This document confirms the legality of
    its activities and compliance with strict online gambling requirements.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/baccarat-guide-how-to-play-win-at-baccarat/

  • online casino usa paypal

    References:
    http://www.jobassembly.com

  • casino sites that accept paypal

    References:
    cyprusjobs.com.cy

  • online betting with paypal winnersbet

    References:
    emploi-securite.com

  • online casino paypal einzahlung

    References:
    cpc.managementdu.ac.bd

Leave a Reply